Acquiring collectibles inside your SMSF

Nov 07, 2022

Clients with self managed superannuation funds (SMSF) often ask what assets the SMSF can acquire. 


‘Why’?

The golden rule for acquiring assets inside your SMSF is why? To be compliant, your fund must be maintained for the sole purpose of providing retirement benefits to members, or to their dependants if a member dies before retirement. The sole purpose test (section 62 of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993), is your starting point. If the collectible you are looking to acquire does not fulfil this purpose, then you have an immediate problem.


Let’s assume you are looking to acquire vintage cars. The question to ask is, is the acquisition a viable investment or simply a desire of the members to own vintage cars. Does the investment ‘stack up’ relative to other forms of investment to build/protect the retirement savings of members?


The sole purpose test extends to how the collectible is managed once acquired. Given the asset is for the sole purpose of the member’s retirement benefits, the members (or their associates) cannot use or enjoy the asset in any way. This means:

  • Storage of the collectible cannot be at the trustee’s residence or displayed at their office. The ATO says, “You can store (but not display) collectables and personal use assets in premises owned by a related party provided it is not their private residence. They can’t be displayed because this means they are being used by the related party. For example, if your SMSF invests in artwork it can’t be hung in the business premises of a related party where it is visible to clients and employees.”
  • Leasing or use of the collectible can only be undertaken with an unrelated party. 
  • The collectible must have its own insurance policy owned by the SMSF (multiple items can be listed on the same policy i.e., wines of different brands). The insurance policy must be in place within 7 days of acquisition.
  • Like all other assets, if a collectible is sold to a related party, then it must be sold at market value. Collectibles also require a qualified independent valuation if sold to a related party.


This means you cannot stay in a holiday home owned by your SMSF, you cannot drive a vehicle owned by the SMSF, and you cannot enjoy artwork held by the SMSF. And, those bottles of Penfolds Grange owned by the SMSF that broke (wink, wink) are likely to trigger an audit as they should have been properly stored in a way that prevents breakage.


Your investment strategy

An SMSF investment strategy should articulate the plan trustees have for a fund and the investments they choose to hold. It should drill down into the reasons why certain assets will be acquired (or sold) and how these choices align to the retirement goals of the members. If your SMSF is considering purchasing collectibles, it is essential that your investment strategy is aligned to these types of investments and articulates why the asset fits within the strategy. This is particularly important if the collectible/s will dominate the types of assets held by the fund, its liquidity, and diversity.


A common question is, can my SMSF purchase, let’s say artwork, from a member or a related party of the fund? The answer is no. SMSFs are not allowed to purchase assets, other than listed shares and business real property, from related parties. But, the SMSF could transfer the artwork to a member as an in-specie lump sum payment if the member meets a condition of release, or sell the asset to the member but only if the transaction is at arms length, and an independent valuation confirms the market value of the asset. 


By Web Maintenance 02 May, 2024
The FBT Update for May 2024 provides information on various topics related to vehicles, tax deductions, asset write-offs, bookkeeping, and the conditions for private use of vehicles by employees.
By Web Maintenance 26 Apr, 2024
The Fringe Benefits Tax (FBT) year ends on 31 March. We’ve outlined the hot spots for employers and employees.
Technology
29 Nov, 2023
A wealth based economy in an inflationary world After 15 years of exceptional global growth it is believed the global economy is heading into a more difficult decade of economic trade. It must be acknowledged that 15 years of economic prosperity has been accelerated through active government and central bank policy, stabilising markets and securing credit during the uncertainty of a post GFC world. Has the 'hands on' policy from global governments removed the dynamic effects of market based economics? We would argue that the historical over involvement of monetary and fiscal policy has prevented the natural function of the business cycle to occur, creating an artificial price action in global economics. Developed nations in particular have experienced substantial appreciation to asset valuations due to excess credit, a by -product of overreaching policy. The consequences of the money market imbalance have formed structurally unsupported demand levels and further embedded inflationary pressures. A world that has operated in a liquidity fuelled disequilibrium cannot properly allocate capital nor can it appropriately quantify risk. Seemingly a necessary pivot to 'fair value' under a normalisation of policy is proving a monumental task as confidence levels remain elevated and disconnected from the true value of the underlying assets. Central Banks have been forced to hike and hike rapidly as transitory inflation was debunked. Proving the global economy was not immune to the mania of pandemic spending and investment. The COVID hysteria may have passed, yet inflation appears to be stickier than expected, still market confidence remains with the 'soft landing' narrative. The global economic risks of Central Bank's narrow path to either not tighten enough or too much is certainly not being acknowledged by market pricing . The risk loving sentiment of the last 15 years has not yet been extinguished by tighter credit. What is the market missing? Global recession risk is likely being understated, particularly with a lagging China and negative domestic household savings. More importantly, the overarching theme for this decade that is being overlooked - stagflation. If inflation persists and unemployment rises we would likely enter a period of stagflation. A period defined by an erosion of purchasing power and significant structural job losses, ultimately curtailing economic growth. We are shifting from a government protected market to a floating market set by 'real' demand, and doubts remain if the market has the dynamic capacity to pivot with government policy and function without central bank liquidity. For a dynamic demand driven market to return we must see consumer and investor behaviours align in the government policy pivot towards tighter credit. The continual push back on recession forecasts accompanied with more than expected rate rises, unable to rein in inflation, supports that developed economies have become dependent upon excess government credit and structural change is required to absorb excess liquidity. In a world where market driven demand is skewed by government backed speculation, short run financial outcomes will be prioritised and market inefficiencies will remain. The disinflationary impacts of rate adjustments will be limited until investment behaviour changes. Investment strategy and market function need a dramatic shift towards long term economic goals, encouraging a more efficient alignment of economic issues and market function. Post pandemic economies must find transformative solutions to clear and systemic generational problems: climate change, the energy transition, deglobalisation and labour shortages. For the Australian market to allocate capital efficiently and operate effectively it requires more than the blunt instrument of rate rises. As changes in the cost of money will not shift investment to operate with a long term focus. Investment behaviour will remain on a per annum basis (short run) until governments adequately incentivise behavioural change, if investment activity is held constant stagflation will remain a risk. The structural change required to address environmental and generational economic issues is a 'catch- 22' to inflation, opportunities for innovation may increase productivity helping to ease inflation, yet the capital required for change is now substantially more expensive adding to inflationary pressures. Furthermore, the added cost of capital in an inflationary world is contributing to the choppiness of markets trying to compute the new normal of 'true value'. When market dynamics may still be skewed to the globalisation model failing to price in the compounding stagflation risks of an increasingly multipolar world. A shift in the optimal duration point of investment is a necessary economic antidote to stagflation and economic stability. We live in a precariously shifting economic climate, which intends to increase the cost of carbon whilst decreasing the cost of living. A contradictory world, enduring a cost of livingcrisis and yet luxury goods have proven to be some of the best defensive equities. The friction of changing macro trends will likely continue a preference towards defensive assets and future facing industries. Australia is uniquely positioned for the transformative decade ahead. We are a major producer of future facing commodities and have the potential to be a key player in the production of green energy. Our characteristics as a net exporter of hard and soft commodities for renewable solutions has the capacity to strengthen the Aussie dollar to the world's commodity dollar. Our currency would become aligned with the long term economic goals of our trading partners. As demand for Aussie dollars grows, our dollar will be a natural hedge against inflation, insulating us against stagflation risks in the long term. The Australian economy is well positioned for wealth based trade and development, however government policy must effectively incentivise the return of dynamic 'long run' market based activity, if we are to be sheltered from stagflation risks. Global macro thematics are changing and individual investors need to be aware of change economics 'the great transition. The inflationary risks change, may pose to your portfolio and the unique opportunities of the Australian market. An inflationary environment exacerbates two inescapable economic constraints for the individual: time and budget restrictions. As they spend more, they work more and save less- purchasing power is eroded. Time value constraints are evidenced in wage growth not satisfying consumer needs due to inflation pressures. An individual must consider a wealth strategy that best addresses time and budget constraints, and therefore improving overall purchasing power. Real assets are an essential buffer to the pressures of income shortfalls. The antidote to structural friction and inflation are assets that provide capital stability and a rate of capital return. These assets give an investor ownership (equity) and a passive form of income, both characteristics are the best defence against the time value constraint in an inflationary world. For the Australian retail investor there are three main areas to improve overall individual wealth: 1) Property: capital conservation and rental income resistant to inflation Property has a proven historical performance in Australia, a strong asset class for capital preservation. The housing crisis and supply/labour shortage is producing rental returns that far outweigh the rate of inflation. An emphasis should be placed on residential property, commercial property appears to be facing greater headwinds. 2) Passive Income: Interest and Dividends Passive income increases an individual's income without any further effort required. Interest and dividends derive income independent of a salary or hourly wage, improving an individual's overall productivity and time constraint. The supplementary income from passive investments can be an added shield against inflation. 3) Super: Future facing industries, commodities and infrastructure The great Australian super is a hugely important tool kit in establishing a self funded retirement, and an underappreciated asset in accumulating individual wealth. Australian superannuation has performed strongly over a historical basis, it also gives retail investors exposure to own positions in more selective institutional offerings. For people at all stages of their working life superannuation strategy must be considered, for two main reasons i) tax advantages can create a greater accumulation of wealth ii) The duration of investment for most people has a significant time horizon, often making it their longest accumulating asset. Therefore plan accordingly, and optimise compounding future returns that can defend your portfolio against inflation. Superannuation is an effective vehicle for ownership in real assets and future facing industries that can generate concessionally taxed income greater than the rate of inflation.at a later date. The global economy is facing a frictional decade of structural economic issues. Inflation is likely to remain present as the cost of a rapidly changing world. Australia is well placed to seize the opportunities of economic change. The individual must consider a capital security strategy in uncertain times, maximising wealth over the long term.
Share by: